What happens before you say “Sit”, “Stay” or “Come” may determine what happens afterwards.
When we think about dog training, we naturally tend to concentrate on what happens after we give a cue.
We say “Sit.”
The dog sits.
We reward them.
Successful training.
But there is an important part of that sequence that we can easily overlook.
What happened before we said anything?
Where was the dog’s attention?
What was happening around them?
Were they calm enough to think?
Were they aware of us?
Was the exercise appropriate for the circumstances?
Good training doesn’t begin with the cue.
It begins a few moments earlier.
Look at the Dog in Front of You
Before asking your retriever to do anything, take a moment to observe them.
Not the dog you trained yesterday.
Not the dog who performed the exercise perfectly in the kitchen this morning.
The dog standing in front of you right now.
Perhaps they’re relaxed and attentive.
Perhaps they’ve just spotted another dog.
Perhaps an interesting scent has captured their attention.
Perhaps they’re becoming excited because they know you’re carrying a retrieving dummy.
All of that matters.
The same dog can find the same exercise very easy in one situation and surprisingly difficult in another.
The behaviour hasn’t necessarily changed.
The circumstances have.
Attention Has to Be Available
Suppose you’re walking with your retriever and decide to practise a sit.
If your dog is already aware of you, one quiet cue may be all that’s necessary.
Now imagine exactly the same dog has just seen another dog running across the field.
You say:
“Sit.”
Nothing happens.
“Sit.”
Still nothing.
“SIT!”
At this point it’s tempting to conclude that the dog is ignoring us.
But there is another possibility.
We began giving instructions before establishing whether communication was available.
That’s a very different training problem.
Connection Before Direction
This is why I place so much importance on a simple principle:
Connection before direction.
It doesn’t mean your dog has to stare continuously into your eyes.
A moment of attention may be enough.
A glance.
A check-in.
A slight pause in whatever they’re doing.
Something that tells you:
“Yes, I know you’re there.”
Now the communication channel is open.
Then give the cue.
That small change can make training feel considerably calmer because we stop competing with everything else for the dog’s attention after we’ve already started asking for behaviour.
Notice the Environment
Good trainers don’t only watch the dog.
They also watch what is happening around the dog.
Imagine you’re practising a stay in the garden.
Everything is going well.
Then a neighbour comes through a gate.
A child runs past.
Another dog appears.
A bird lands nearby.
From our perspective, we’re still asking for exactly the same stay.
From the dog’s perspective, the exercise may have changed enormously.
Recognising that before giving the next cue allows us to make a better decision.
Perhaps we continue.
Perhaps we shorten the duration.
Perhaps we move further away from the distraction.
Perhaps we decide this isn’t the moment to make the exercise harder.
That isn’t avoiding training.
It’s managing training intelligently.
Ask Yourself: “Is Success Likely?”
This is a question I think every dog owner would benefit from asking more often.
Before giving the cue:
Is my dog reasonably likely to succeed?
Not guaranteed.
Training inevitably involves progression and challenge.
But reasonably likely.
If the answer is yes, ask.
If the answer is no, change something first.
Move further from the distraction.
Wait for excitement to settle.
Reduce the distance.
Shorten the duration.
Re-establish connection.
Then ask.
We don’t help dogs learn by repeatedly putting them into situations in which they’re likely to fail.
We help them learn by creating successful repetitions and gradually increasing what we’re asking of them.
Your Own Behaviour Matters Too
There is another part of the picture.
Before giving a cue, take a moment to consider what you are doing.
Are you clear about what you’re asking?
Are you about to use the same cue you’ve taught previously?
Are you standing differently?
Are you holding food in a way that has accidentally become part of the signal?
Are you feeling rushed or frustrated?
Dogs are excellent observers.
Sometimes we’re communicating far more with our body than with the word we’re about to say.
Clear training starts with clarity at both ends of the lead.
One Cue Should Mean Something
If we establish connection first, something else becomes easier.
We don’t need to keep repeating ourselves.
“Sit.”
“Sit.”
“Come on, sit.”
“I said sit.”
Repeated cues can gradually become background noise.
Instead:
Notice.
Connect.
Then:
Ask once, clearly.
Give the dog time to respond.
If the response doesn’t come, don’t immediately assume you need to say it again.
Ask yourself what happened.
That little pause can tell you far more than another repetition of the cue.
Preparation Isn’t the Same as Control
None of this means carefully arranging the world so that your dog never encounters difficulty.
Dogs need experience.
They need gradually increasing challenges.
They need to learn to respond in different places and around different distractions.
But there is a difference between progressively preparing a dog for difficulty and suddenly testing them against it.
A dog who succeeds at home isn’t automatically ready to perform exactly the same behaviour in a busy park.
We build towards that.
Step by step.
Successful repetition by successful repetition.
That’s how reliability develops.
Sometimes the Best Cue Is No Cue
There will also be occasions when observation tells you:
Not now.
Perhaps the dog is overwhelmed.
Perhaps the distraction is too great.
Perhaps they’re tired.
Perhaps you’re tired.
Perhaps there is simply no useful training outcome to be gained from asking at that moment.
Choosing not to give a cue isn’t a missed opportunity.
Sometimes it’s the best training decision available.
There will always be another opportunity.
Good Training Becomes Quieter
As we become better at preparing before asking, something interesting often happens.
Training becomes quieter.
Fewer repeated commands.
Less frustration.
Less conflict.
More successful responses.
The owner begins watching more and talking less.
And the dog begins to discover that our communication is clear, predictable and worth paying attention to.
That is a very different relationship from one in which we spend our time continually calling the dog’s name and repeating instructions.
Notice → Connect → Ask
If you want a simple way to remember all of this, begin with three steps:
NOTICE
What is my dog doing?
What is happening around us?
CONNECT
Is my dog aware of me?
Is communication available?
ASK
Now give one clear cue.
What happens afterwards—how we reinforce the response and how we gradually progress the behaviour—matters enormously.
But successful training often begins with those first few seconds.
Final Thoughts
We tend to judge a training exercise by what happens after we give the cue.
Did the dog sit?
Did they stay?
Did they come back?
But perhaps we should occasionally judge our own training by what happened before we asked.
Did we notice?
Did we establish connection?
Did we make success reasonably achievable?
Were we clear about what we wanted?
Those are decisions the trainer makes.
And when we make them well, the dog’s job becomes much easier.
So the next time you’re about to ask your retriever to do something, resist the temptation to immediately give the cue.
Take a second.
Look at your dog.
Look around you.
Establish connection.
Then ask.
Because very often, the success of the next few seconds is determined by what you did in the few seconds before them.
A Thought for This Week
Choose one familiar behaviour your retriever already knows.
Perhaps Sit.
Before asking for it, deliberately spend two or three seconds doing nothing except observing.
Where is your dog’s attention?
What is happening around you?
Is communication available?
Wait for that small moment of connection.
Then give the cue once.
Try this several times in different everyday situations.
Don’t concentrate only on whether your dog responds.
Notice whether changing what you do before the cue changes what happens after it.
Leave a Reply